We use cookies to make your experience better. Learn more about how and why.

Preferences Deny Accept

Ep. 47 | Clicks, Clarity, & Community: Rethinking Your Nonprofit Website

In this episode of Beyond the Donation, Matt Bitzegaio sits down with David Hartstein from Wired Impact to explore what makes a nonprofit website truly effective. They dive into the common challenges small to mid-sized nonprofits face when it comes to web design, and why a well-crafted website is more than just a nice-to-have—it's your 24/7 digital storefront.

David shares practical advice on conducting website audits, improving accessibility, and simplifying homepage design to better serve visitors. You'll also hear how AI is shifting the SEO landscape, and what that means for creating content that ranks and resonates. Whether you're working with a shoestring budget or looking for quick wins, this conversation is packed with actionable tips to help your website do more for your mission.

00:00 Introduction and Guest Welcome

00:17 David Hartstein's Background and Wired Impact

01:52 Importance of a Well-Designed Website

04:32 Budget Constraints and Website Prioritization

06:23 Conducting a Website Audit

08:57 Key Elements of a Nonprofit Homepage

12:51 Impact of AI on SEO and Website Design

19:10 Website Accessibility

26:15 Final Tips and Resources

Additional Resources:

To Connect with David:

David LinkedIn | Wired Impact

To Connect with Beyond the Donation Podcast:

BTD Podcast | DonorDock LinkedIn | Matt LinkedIn

What is the five-second test for a nonprofit website?

The five-second test asks: when someone lands on your homepage, can they understand who you are, what you do, and why they should care within five seconds — without scrolling? Check the headline (plain language, not just org name), who you serve, at least one piece of proof (number, story, or quote), one clear call to action, and visuals that show real work. If a friend forwarded your homepage, would the recipient instantly understand?

Last updated

April 25, 2026

What is a nonprofit clarity audit?

A nonprofit clarity audit is a quick review of all donor-facing materials — website, donation page, emails, social, print — to answer one question: would a brand-new supporter understand what you do and trust you within seconds? It tests whether your message is consistent across channels and whether each piece passes the five-second test of clarity, proof, and call-to-action.

Last updated

April 25, 2026

What should I remove from my nonprofit About page?

Dense founder histories, inside-baseball language like "capacity building" or "stakeholders," and every "we are committed to" phrase. Replace them with the donor's role, concrete outcome data, and direct calls to action. If a paragraph does not move the donor toward giving, joining, or trusting — cut it.

Last updated

April 25, 2026

What should be on a nonprofit's About page?

A strong nonprofit About page opens with the problem you solve, names the donor as the hero who makes solutions possible, then shows the team and track record that prove you can execute. Mission statements, founding dates, and staff bios come after the donor-centered narrative — not before. Most nonprofits get this order backwards.

Last updated

April 25, 2026

Author

Sarah O'Brien

Marketing and Outreach Manager

Last updated:

April 28, 2026

Written by

Sarah O'Brien

Marketing and Outreach Manager

Read similar articles

What is a Nonprofit CRM? The 2026 Guide for Growing and Mid-Sized Nonprofits

A buyer's primer on what a nonprofit CRM is, how it differs from sales CRMs and adjacent fundraising tools, and how to evaluate the right fit for a growing development team.

Why Email Still Outperforms Every Other Fundraising Channel

Email generates $54 per 1,000 messages while social media converts just 5% of donors. Here is why email-first fundraising is the smartest revenue play.

How to Build a Planned Giving Program: A Step-by-Step Guide

A planned giving program does not require a large team or budget. Here is a seven-step guide to launching legacy giving at your growing nonprofit.

Start building meaningful donor relationships today.

Your fundraising in one place.

Schedule a Demo View Pricing

Donor Dock-Shapes1-06