%20(1).jpg)
If you’ve ever thought, “our board is supportive, just not in fundraising,” you’re not alone. Most boards genuinely want to help. They just need clear expectations, simple training, and healthy accountability. That combination turns good intentions into real dollars and stronger donor relationships.
In this guide, we’ll walk you through a practical playbook you can run this quarter. It’s built for small and growing fundraisers who want more focus in their board support and less frenzy in their week. We’ll set the foundation, equip your board to act, and build an accountability rhythm people actually enjoy.
Clarity beats pep talks. If it isn’t written, it doesn’t exist.
Start with clarity, not cheerleading
Fundraising starts with governance. Board members are fiduciaries who help make sure your nonprofit has the resources to advance the mission. That responsibility includes personal giving and tangible support for fundraising.
So let’s get the essentials in writing before and during board service:
Role descriptions that say the quiet part out loud. Document personal giving expectations, stewardship activities, and ambassador duties. Review this during recruitment and orientation so no one is surprised later. The National Council of Nonprofits offers practical orientation guidance you can adapt. (National Council of Nonprofits)
A 100% board giving policy. Set the expectation that every director makes a personally meaningful gift each year. Funders often ask about board participation, and 100% signals shared commitment. BoardSource recommends boards that raise funds target 100% participation. Whether it is $25 or $25,000, the message is the same: I believe in this work. (BoardSource)
A choose-your-own-adventure fundraising menu. Give directors an on-ramp that matches their comfort and network. For example, you might ask each member to pick two actions for the next 30 days. Here are sample options to include in your menu, followed by a bit of color on how they play out:
- Make a personally meaningful annual gift. Treat this as step one, not the finish line. It unlocks credibility in every ask you make alongside that director.
- Send 10 warm introductions this quarter. Provide a one-paragraph case for support and a short intro email template so the lift feels light.
- Host a small “mission meetup.” A living room or coffee shop conversation with 6 to 10 friends is often less intimidating than a gala and sparks authentic questions.
- Complete two stewardship touchpoints monthly. Thank-you calls and handwritten notes build trust faster than any brochure.
- Share one story post on LinkedIn each month. Offer a prewritten story and a clear call to action to make posting easy.
Want examples and templates your board can use right away? Point them to DonorDock’s Nonprofit Board of Directors 101 and Recruiting engaged and effective board members to align expectations and onboarding.
Train and equip your board to succeed
Most boards underinvest in relationship-building time. BoardSource’s Leading with Intent reports that 67% of executives say boards do not spend enough time building community relationships that support and inform the work. That gap is fixable with practical training and plug-and-play tools. (BoardSource)
67% of executives say boards do not spend enough time building community relationships
Here’s a tight, 60-minute “Fundraising for Board Members” lab you can facilitate at your next meeting:
Minutes 0 to 15: Story and outcomes. Share one crisp narrative, two program “prices,” and three proof points. Keep it human and specific. Your board should be able to repeat this story to a friend in an elevator.
Minutes 15 to 30: The three simple asks. Practice saying: 1) “Join me for a tour,” 2) “Would you give today,” 3) “Could you introduce me to X.” These are clear next steps that any director can use.
Minutes 30 to 45: Role-play in pairs. Two low-stakes donor scenarios and a debrief. Keep it kind and practical.
Minutes 45 to 60: Commitments. Each director chooses two menu actions they’ll complete in the next 30 days.
Equip the group with tools that make action easy:
- A one-page case for support with two program price points
- Email and text templates for intros and thank-yous
- A monthly “top prospects” list so directors know who to call
- A 3-question debrief after every touchpoint: What did you learn, what’s the next step, and who owns it
If you want to layer in cultivation structure, share Mastering moves management for a simple way to think about donor journeys, and line up board-specific tactics with From advisors to advocates: board-driven year-end giving as an example of focused seasonal outreach.
Build healthy accountability people actually enjoy
Clear expectations stick when leaders model them and follow up consistently. Create a no-blame scoreboard that measures effort and celebrates progress, not perfection.
Quarterly dashboard. Track five simple metrics: 100% personal giving, number of donor introductions, stewardship touchpoints, visits completed, and dollars influenced. Share the aggregate at the board level and keep individual details with the chair and CEO.
Peer pairing. Match directors with a buddy. They block one outreach hour together each month. Accountability feels better in pairs.
Ambassador-of-the-month. Spotlight a director who made helpful intros, shared a post that converted, or hosted a great meetup. Recognition fuels momentum.
Friction removal. If someone stalls, ask why. Is it clarity, confidence, or capacity? Offer scripts, join the first call, or right-size the commitment.
Board meeting redesign. Open with a donor story and a 10-minute relationship-building exercise. Use a consent agenda to reclaim time from reports, then spend that time on outreach practice and booking next actions before everyone leaves.
Accountability is kindness. It tells busy people exactly how to win.
For a streamlined plan your team can run without a giant spreadsheet, see The 5-8 fundraising plays that actually work. It will help you cut through the noise, keep the cadence steady, and focus on what matters most.
Your first 30 days, simplified
Use this rollout to get momentum quickly. Think more focus, less frenzy.
Week 1. Adopt a written board giving and fundraising policy that targets 100% participation. Reference BoardSource’s guidance as your north star and adjust the language to fit your culture. Pair it with updated role descriptions and orientation materials so expectations are clear from day one.
Week 2. Host the 60-minute lab. Deliver the one-page case, outreach templates, and a prioritized prospect list. Each director chooses two menu items for the next 30 days.
Week 3. Launch the no-blame scoreboard. Include the dashboard in the board packet. The chair and CEO make two joint donor visits with board members to set the tone.
Week 4. Celebrate wins in the meeting. Name what worked, remove friction, refresh the prospect list, and book next month’s actions while calendars are open.
To keep learning simple for new board members and staff, share DonorDock’s Fundraising 101: Basics that strengthen every ask so everyone speaks the same language.
Why this works
Governance alignment. You honor the board’s duty to ensure adequate resources while keeping staff in the lead on strategy and execution. That is squarely within the board’s fiduciary role.
Credibility with funders. 100% board giving signals shared commitment. It is an easy way to strengthen every ask you and your board make together.
Culture shift. Clear expectations plus small wins create momentum. That momentum turns “we should” into “we did,” and it sustains itself when you track progress and celebrate people.
You do not need a board of celebrity rainmakers. You need a board that’s clear on expectations, equipped to act, and lovingly held accountable. Start small. Celebrate often. Keep the flywheel turning.
Ready to equip your board and track the right actions in one place so you can ease your mental load and focus on what matters most? Schedule a demo and start building meaningful donor relationships today.
.jpg)
