Small Team, High Leverage: The 3x3 System to Operate Like a Bigger Shop

You don’t need a giant development department to raise more money and build stronger donor relationships. What you need is focus.

This playbook introduces a simple 3x3 system for small and growing fundraising teams. It helps you cut through the noise, multiply your effort, and build momentum without adding headcount.

Before we dive in, let’s zoom out. Charitable giving grew to $592.50 billion in 2024, but many teams still feel strapped for time and attention. Dollars are up, while donor counts and retention remain uneven. The result: even more pressure on small teams to work smarter. (Giving USA)

The 3x3 framework

The 3x3 is a grid: three improvement types by three focus areas.

Improvement types

1. Prioritize
2. Batch
3. Automate or Offload

Focus areas

1. People
2. Process
3. Platforms

Read it left to right and you’ll see nine places where you can create leverage this month. Let’s walk through them with examples and lightweight rituals you can start this week.

Small shifts across People, Process, and Platforms free up hours you can spend with donors. That’s the goal.

‍

1) Prioritize x People, Process, Platforms

People. Not every donor needs the same kind of attention. Focus 1-to-1 time on those most likely to deepen their commitment, while serving others well with thoughtful 1-to-many touches.. A simple segmentation is enough to decide who gets a call, who gets a handwritten note, and who gets a great newsletter. If you need a starting point, check out these 6 donor segments.

Process. Get clear on the steps that actually move revenue and relationships, then make them part of your weekly rhythm. Example priorities:

• 5 discovery or thank-you calls
• 10 handwritten notes
• 1 block for board outreach
• 1 hour of portfolio hygiene

Platforms. Audit your tools for what matters most: clean data and easy follow-up. If a feature doesn’t help you steward, solicit, or report, it can wait.

Why this matters: in 2024, new donor retention dropped even as overall dollars went up. (Fundraising Effectiveness Project)

2) Batch x People, Process, Platforms

People. Group similar tasks so you’re not constantly shifting gears. Block two 45-minute windows for calls and do nothing else during that time. Draft all your stewardship emails in one sitting and schedule them.

Process. Bundle the operational chores that usually splinter your attention:

• Deposit and reconcile gifts at the same time each week
• Approve creative and event collateral in a single review block
• Prep next week’s top-25 outreach list every Friday afternoon

Platforms. Create templates and snippets so you’re not reinventing the wheel. For example, draft three email shells you can personalize in seconds: a thank-you, a quick update, and an impact story.

Research shows batching works. Psychologists have long documented the “switching costs” that pile up when you jump between tasks. Even small delays add up across the day. (American Psychological Association)

“Busy is not the same as effective.” Batching lightens your mental load and creates space for real human connection.

3) Automate or Offload x People, Process, Platforms

People. Use light automation to scale the touches you already do. A triggered welcome series after a first gift helps warm new supporters while you focus personal follow-ups on donors who show deeper signals. Here’s a guide on automated donor journeys.

Process. Document a task once, then delegate it. Think gift receipts, event check-ins, or your monthly newsletter layout. Volunteers are back in force, and their contributions are valuable. The value of a volunteer hour was $34.79 in 2024. A few saved hours each week add up quickly. (Independent Sector)

Platforms. Let your systems do more of the heavy lifting:

• Auto-create a “call in 48 hours” task for any gift over $250
• Tag new donors and trigger a 3-email nurture
• Set alerts when a lapsed donor opens an appeal three times

If you want a friendly assistant to keep touches moving, meet Otto, our AI-powered helper that makes sure you steward on time and with heart. (How nonprofits stop “shoulding” themselves with Otto)

And because inboxes are more crowded than ever, automation protects your lift. In 2024, nonprofits sent an average of 62 emails per subscriber, raising $58 per 1,000 fundraising emails. Volume is up, response is tighter, and targeted automation helps you land messages when they matter most. (M+R Benchmarks 2025)

Your weekly operating rhythm

Here’s a simple cadence small teams can use to stay focused without burning out:

Monday

• 30-minute standup to confirm top 3 outcomes for the week
• 45 minutes of stewardship calls
• 30 minutes to update gifts, notes, and tasks

Tuesday

• 60-minute prospecting block
• 30 minutes to draft a donor story and prep social copy
• 30 minutes to tidy platforms and review automations

Wednesday

• 45 minutes of visits or Zooms with priority donors
• 30 minutes of handwritten notes for gifts over $100
• 15 minutes to check in with volunteers

Thursday

• 60 minutes of grant or campaign work
• 30 minutes of board outreach
• 15 minutes of data hygiene

Friday

• 30-minute review to celebrate wins and clear blockers
• 45 minutes to prep next week’s top-25 outreach list
• 15 minutes to review automations and pick one new task to offload

“Ruthless elimination of more.” Keep the rhythm small and repeatable. If a new task doesn’t beat a current block on outcomes, it waits.

Quick wins by quadrant

Here are a few easy starting points:

Prioritize x People

• Identify your 25 most-likely-to-upgrade donors and book 5 touchpoints this week
• Use the Relationship Loop: listen, reflect, respond

Prioritize x Process

• Define two metrics to move in the next 90 days. Example: repeat donor retention and second-gift size

Prioritize x Platforms

• Hide features you don’t use and pin the three screens you need daily

Batch x People

• Create a “notes hour” every Thursday to close loops on meetings and calls

Batch x Process

• Turn receipt chaos into a single Friday block that includes reconciling and pulling a thank-you list

Batch x Platforms

• Build three reusable email templates. Personalize the first and last line

Automate/Offload x People

• Trigger a welcome series for first-time donors, then schedule a call on day 10 for anyone who clicks your story

Automate/Offload x Process

• Write a 1-page SOP for volunteer reception and hand it off next week

Automate/Offload x Platforms

• Set alerts only for meaningful intent. Example: when a lapsed donor opens two stewardship emails in a week

For a deeper dive on balancing tech with human connection, see this piece on fundraising automation and the human equation.

A 30-day rollout plan

• Week 1. Map your 3x3 and pick one cell in each row to improve
• Week 2. Build your weekly rhythm and cut one low-value meeting
• Week 3. Launch one automation and one volunteer handoff
• Week 4. Evaluate. Did you create more time for donor conversations? If yes, expand. If not, simplify

Remember: dollars are up, attention is down. The teams that thrive focus on what matters most, keep relationships at the center, and use batching and automation to protect their best hours.

Final nudge

If your brain feels like it has too many tabs open, you’re not imagining it. Research shows interruptions increase time pressure and stress. Guardrails like batching and automation let you show up calm, present, and ready for the humans who fund your mission. (Gloria Mark, interrupted work study)

Want to put this 3x3 system into practice inside your CRM? Try DonorDock to build clean segments, set up smart automations, and nudge the right next step every day. Start building meaningful donor relationships today.